My Stuff

https://umass-my.sharepoint.com/:f:/g/personal/rwolff_umass_edu/EkxJV79tnlBDol82i7bXs7gBAUHadkylrmLgWbXv2nYq_A?e=UcbbW0

Coming Soon:

The following books by Robert Paul Wolff are available on Amazon.com as e-books: KANT'S THEORY OF MENTAL ACTIVITY, THE AUTONOMY OF REASON, UNDERSTANDING MARX, UNDERSTANDING RAWLS, THE POVERTY OF LIBERALISM, A LIFE IN THE ACADEMY, MONEYBAGS MUST BE SO LUCKY, AN INTRODUCTION TO THE USE OF FORMAL METHODS IN POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY.
Now Available: Volumes I, II, III, and IV of the Collected Published and Unpublished Papers.

NOW AVAILABLE ON YOUTUBE: LECTURES ON KANT'S CRITIQUE OF PURE REASON. To view the lectures, go to YouTube and search for "Robert Paul Wolff Kant." There they will be.

NOW AVAILABLE ON YOUTUBE: LECTURES ON THE THOUGHT OF KARL MARX. To view the lectures, go to YouTube and search for Robert Paul Wolff Marx."





Total Pageviews

Wednesday, October 8, 2014

MARX AND FREUD


Chris Byron, a frequent commentator on this blog, asks me “How do you square your Freud with your Marx? Civilization and Its Discontents and The Future of An Illusion (especially the first chapter) are wholly antagonistic to ANY decent form of socialism or Marxist project.”

This raises [perhaps unintentionally] an extremely interesting and important question about how to read and what to make of what one reads.  As is my custom, I shall answer these questions personally and subjectively, by describing how I read and what I make of what I read, but in this case, I really do mean to suggest that this is the right way to read, not just my way.

In student papers, one often comes across this sort of locution:  “In this part of my paper I use Rawls …”  The implication is that Rawls is one of a number of tools one has lying around, which one can pick up and use for some purpose or other.  But Rawls, Plato, Hume, Kant, Rousseau, and Nietzsche are not tools, instruments, hammers, levers, pry bars, or chisels.  Nor are Freud and Marx.  They are authors who have written books in which they presented arguments in support of various theses, analyses of various concepts, reports of assorted research.  I may be informed, enlightened, provoked, inspired by these arguments, analyses, and reports [or confused, misled, bored, or depressed by them, needless to say], and when putting my own arguments, analyses, or reports of research in written form, I may wish to pay my respects to an author with a footnote [although that is really only a form of homage, and not in any way a strengthening of the argument, a sharpening of the analysis, or a lending of credence to the research]. 

Some of the authors to whom I pay my respects in my writings may be, as it were, my comrades in a grand struggle for liberation or social justice.  Some may not.  But I do not deny myself the benefits of such inspiration or enlightenment as I may derive from reading an author merely because he or she is not in that sense my comrade.  And regardless of my relationship to the authors I cite, I take full responsibility for whatever arguments I advance, and never seek to hide behind the reputation of those who may have been so kind as to provide me with inspiration or enlightenment.  Thus it is that, apparently to the surprise of some of my readers, I often pay my respects to Michael Oakeshott, from whom I have learned, despite the fact that he was a Tory.

Which brings me to Freud and Marx.  From Freud I have learned much about the structure and functioning of the human mind, about motivation and self-deception and obsession and the existence and role of the unconscious.  What I have learned from Freud on these matters is so thoroughly integrated into my understanding of human motivation that I would be hard put to delineate the outer limits of what he has taught me.  I have learned even more from Marx, as I am sure I have made clear on numerous occasions on this blog.  But because I have made what I learned from Freud and Marx my own, integrating it into my larger understanding of the social world, I and I alone am responsible for the truth of what I now believe.  It would never occur to me to hide behind the enormous reputations of those authors by saying, when challenged, “I was using Freud there” or “I got that from Marx,” as though by reading their books I had acquired hit points from them, as my sons used to say when playing Dungeons and Dragons.

Thus, the question “How do you square your Freud with your Marx?” betrays, in my judgment, an entirely misguided notion of how one should think of the authors from whom one has learned.  In particular, I am in no way compelled to embrace Freud’s musings on religion or culture as the price of learning from him about the unconscious.  That way of thinking is a secular version of religious sectarianism, and I abjure it completely.

However, there is a large and important question here that is sometimes alluded to in shorthand as “making Freud compatible with Marx,” a question that engaged the efforts of some of the most interesting graduates of the Frankfort School for Social Research.  Freud was a doctor who spent many hours every working day seeing patients.  [I have written about this at some length in my tutorial, The Thought of Sigmund Freud.]  As a medical specialist, a neurologist, he constantly tested his generalizations about the mind against his clinical observations and the success or failure of his treatment of his patients.  From his clinical experiences, he formulated generalizations about the mind that he hoped would apply to persons other than those whom he had treated.  These were bold, far-reaching generalizations, but they were always about the ways in which the individual human mind works.  As a neurologist, he believed that eventually it would be possible to find the physical causes and correlates in the nervous system of everything he had discovered in his clinical practice, but during his lifetime, the equipment to undertake the investigation of those physical correlates did not yet exist.  Nothing in Future of an Illusion or Civilization and its Discontents follows in any rigorous or logically necessary way from his clinically grounded discoveries about the individual human mind.

Marx undertook the most extensive empirical research into the operations of a capitalist economy of anyone up to and including his own day, drawing on a wide range of data, and elaborating a sophisticated and powerful theory of capitalism that remains even now illuminating and valuable, despite the fact that much more is known now about the functioning of a capitalist system than could have been known in his day [and despite the fact that capitalism itself has changed considerably in the intervening 147 years.]  He also speculated brilliantly about the subjective experience of capitalism, both in his early writings and in Capital.  But he had nothing remotely like the fully worked out theory of the human mind that Freud developed.

A number of social theorists associated with the Frankfurt Institute for Social Research attempted to bring the insights of Freud and Marx into fruitful conjunction, none more brilliantly, in my judgment, than Herbert Marcuse, whose notion of “surplus repression,” set forth in his 1955 work Eros and Civilization is a masterstroke of invention and synthesis in the service of a radical socialist vision.  Anyone who wonders how to square Freud with Marx would do well to start there.

DARK DOINGS

I took my first Paris morning walk this morning [in a light rain -- Audrey Hepburn may think that the first time you see Paris it should be raining -- Sabrina -- but I would have been just as happy to stay dry.]  When I neared the end of the first half, I saw the row of batobuses lined up on the Seine.  There was the Yves Montand, just as I expected.  But the Jean Gabin was gone!!  I do not know what mischief is afoot in the French cinematic world, but it does not look good.

YOU KNOW YOU ARE OLD WHEN ...

The driver who took us from Heathrow to St. Pancras station for the Eurostar to Paris was a native Londoner of Indian or Pakistani extraction who asked if it was all right for him to play some pop music on the radio "to help him wake up."  He found a loud selection [which Susie identified as the BeeGees -- lord knows how], and when Susie said she liked it but I probably did not, he asked what sort of music I like.  I said "something three hundred years older."  He thought for a moment and said, "Like Frank Sinatra."

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

J'ARRIVE J'ARRIVE


My next door neighbors from 1971 to 1980 in Northampton were the Bagg family – Bob Bagg, a UMass English Professor, Sally Bagg, a cellist [in whose parents’ home they then lived], and five children, Teddy, Chris, Jonathan, Melissa, and Hazard.  Hazzie was a bit older than my older son, Patrick.  Bob is a poet – one of the “Amherst poets” in the line that began with Robert Frost and continued through Richard Wilbur [with whose beautiful wife I danced in the American Academy in Rome on New Year’s Eve 1954, when I had just turned twenty-one and she was amusing herself by vamping me.]  Jonathan is now the violist of the Ciompi Quartet, which is in residence at Duke University, where Susie and I have heard him several times.

One of Bob’s poems concerns a meeting with a woman, in which there appears the line “J’arrive, J’arrive.”  I think the meeting takes place on the Riviera, but it is forty years and more since I have read the poem.  Anyway, I always think that is what I should say when I get to Paris, so:

J’arrive, J’arrive!

Sunday, October 5, 2014

AND SO TO PARIS

Once again, Susie and I are going to Paris, this time for a short stay of just four weeks.  Barring trouble with FranceTelecom, I should be back in the blogosphere on Tuesday.  We return November 2nd, in time to vote in what looks increasingly like a very unhappy election.  My next early morning walk will be past Notre Dame, along the Seine to the National Assembly and back.  We shall see whether the bateaubuses Jean Gabin and Yves Montand are still there.

AT T. GENT'S REQUEST


T. Gent invites me to tell stories about C. I. Lewis, a request that surely he [she?] knows I find it impossible to deny.  I shan't say "Stop me if you have heard this one," because in fact those of you who have read my Autobiography have heard most of my stories about Lewis.  Think of this as a family gathering at which Grandfather is encouraged to tell once again the old familiar stories that his children and grandchildren have heard so often.  The enjoyment is not in the stories, which everyone knows by heart, but in the evident pleasure it gives the old man to tell them.

When I arrived at Harvard in 1950, Lewis was in his last years as a professor in the Philosophy Department.  Although there were other senior professors who had either just retired [such as Ralph Barton Perry] or would retire not too long after Lewis [like Raphael Demos], Lewis was very much the grand old man of the Department, at least in our student eyes.  There were at that time a group of young, relatively newly tenured men [you understand that this was long before the Department would even consider hiring a woman, let along tenuring one] --  Willard van Orman Quine, Henry Aiken, Morton White.  I always thought, without any real confirmation, that they felt somewhat stifled by the weight of the departmental heritage and longed to break free from its burden.  We students idolized Lewis, a fact that seemed to rankle with the Young Turks [as I thought of them.]   One story, just to get ahead of myself, will serve to illustrate this.  Lewis retired in 1953, and moved with his wife, Mabel, to California.  The next year he was invited back to give a talk, and contrary to long departmental custom, the faculty as well as the students turned out for the event.  One of the bizarre traditions of the Department was that when a visiting professor came to lecture, no one from the Department would show up.  It was great for the graduate students, who got to ask questions rather than just sitting there like mushrooms, but I often thought it must have puzzled the visitors and perhaps made the more sensitive among them feel snubbed.  At any event, there we all were for Lewis' talk.  When it ended, everyone applauded, and then I stood up to give him a standing ovation.  Other students followed suit, and I saw a look of extremely displeasure on Henry Aiken's face as he was virtually dragged to his feet by some lingering sense of propriety to honor someone he thought he had finally gotten rid of.  I wonder whether that is why Aiken gave me such a hard time on my pre-doctoral oral, but that is another story.

My first encounter with Lewis was in the Fall of 1952, when I took his undergraduate course on Epistemology.  As an eighteen year old senior, I was quite full of myself, and, having taken a course on Hume's Treatise the year before [with Aiken], I wrote a final paper that picked away at some of Hume's claims about impressions and ideas in true Analytic Philosophy fashion.  Lewis treated the paper more gently than it deserved, and made a comment that has stayed with me for the intervening sixty-two years.  After remarking that "in this paper it would be out of place to ask that [the points] should 'add up' to something in conclusion," he wrote: "I should hope that this general character of the paper is not a symptom of that type of mind, in philosophy, which can find the objection to everything but advance the solution to nothing."  I cannot imagine Quine or Aiken or White writing such a comment in those days.

Lewis was a slender man who held himself erect despite his great age [he was, at that point, perhaps ten years younger than I am now.]  He always wore brown three piece suits, and affected pince-nez.  He spoke with somewhat pursed lips [rather like Ronnie Dworkin, it occurs to me now for the first time -- he and Lewis in a way looked alike.]  He was a figure from a bygone era -- this was, after all, during the Korean War, for heaven's sake -- and I am told that not even his colleagues called him anything but Mr. Lewis [though I imagine Raphael Demos called him Clarence.]  It would never have crossed my mind to have a casual chat with him or -- God forbid -- hang out, though there were graduate students who thought nothing of going out for a beer with Henry  Aiken or Van Quine.  Perhaps I should explain, for my younger readers, that in those far-distant days one simply did not cut class or hand a paper in late.  If necessary, you stayed up all night writing it, but at the appointed hour it was handed in.  I can still recall the shocked reaction to a group of undergraduates at Columbia whom I was teaching in 1964 during my first semester there.  I assigned a paper and on the due date a third or more of the students failed to turn it in.  "It will be very hard to pass this course if you do not hand in the paper," I said, and they all sat there staring blankly.  "So those of you who did not submit a paper had better run back to your rooms and spend the next hour churning out something."  They still did not budge -- in  shock, I imagine.  Finally I yelled, "Get up and go!" and they scurried off.  They all did hand in something or other by the end of the hour, even if it was only their notes for the paper they intended sometime or other to write.  Columbia was like that.  One year, in a Department Meeting, we were discussing the lamentable fact that students were presenting themselves for the defense of their doctoral dissertations with a number of Incompletes still on their records.  I proposed that we pass a motion requiring graduate students to complete as course in the academic year in which they took it.  It was summarily voted down as entirely unworkable.

But I digress.  My next story is not really mine to tell, but since Ronnie Dworkin is no longer with us, perhaps I may.  At Harvard [and perhaps elsewhere -- I do not know] Phi Beta Kappa has the practice of admitting a select few students in their Junior Year because of their outstanding records.  [I graduated after only three years, but I would not have been one of the Junior Eight anyway -- you needed virtually all A's for that.  I did make Phi Bete at graduation.  My big sister, Barbara, who graduated summa from Swarthmore, had of course made Phi Bete also, and when I came home with my new gold key, my mother appropriated both mine and Barbara's and had a pair of earrings made from them for herself.  But I would not want you to think she was at all competitive with her sisters-in-law.]  As you might expect, Ronnie Dworkin was Junior Phi Bete.  Well, the Society had a custom of inviting some distinguished member of the faculty to address their annual meeting.  Lewis was tapped by the selection committee, and since Ronnie was a Philosophy major, he was deputized to go see the old man and invite him.  As Ronnie told the story afterward, when I asked Lewis to be the Phi Beta Kappa speaker that year, Lewis smiled sadly and declined, saying that as he had not been elected to the society, he thought it would be inappropriate.  Ronnie sais that he wanted to cry, "It's all right, Clarence.  You have made up for it!" but he simply nodded and reported back.

Since I have so often made reference to Lewis' famous Kant course, perhaps I should take a few moments to explain how he ran it.  The sole assigned reading was the Critique, in the Kemp Smith translation.  Each week, we were assigned between thirty and sixty pages of the text, seriatim, and were required to write a summary of the passage.  The summary was to be four to seven pages long, and was to reproduce every heading and sub-heading in the text.  Along the left hand margin we were to keep a running tabulation of the pages of the text we were summarizing.  [Kant published two extremely important versions of the Critique -- the First Edition in 1781 and the Second Edition in 1787.  Because the changes in the Second Edition are substantial and philosophically of the first importance, all modern editions and translations include both variants.  To keep track, the original first and second edition pagination is printed in the text, usually in the margin, and we were to follow that practice.] 

These were summaries, you understand, not interpretations or our critical opinions or allusions to other philosophers -- just summaries.  The assigned length was deliberately -- we thought maliciously -- designed to force to make a series of difficult choices about what to include and what to omit.  Fewer pages and we could simply have skated along the surface of the text;  more pages would have allowed us to include everything.  We were also compelled to master the eighteenth century philosophical terminology Kant used, along with his innovations.  One summary was due each week, and there was no question about turning one in late.  if you fell behind, you might as well drop the course!  The summaries were graded by a graduate student and handed back fast enough so that you could learn from your mistakes before the next one was due.  My year, Hugo Bedau, later my very good friend and now sadly departed, was the grader.  When I gave the course seven years later, I graded all the summaries myself, not trusting some graduate student who had never studied the Critique with me.  That first year twenty-six students took my Kant course and wrote eleven summaries each.  Two hundred and seventy-one summaries, plus the final exams.

Writing the Kant summaries was the hardest work I ever did in any course.  Each one took maybe twenty hours a week -- Basic Training of the mind.  It was far and away the greatest educational experience of my life, and as it turned out, led directly to my first, and maybe my best, book.  Several years after Lewis retired, some of us got together to pool our notes in an effort to immortalize his lectures, but to our surprise we found that there was not much in the notes.  What then had made this the best course any of us had ever taken?  For that it was the best course, indeed probably the best Philosophy course taught anywhere by anyone since Plato lectured to Aristotle we had no doubt.

Each of us who was fortunate enough to take the course must have his own my answer.  My answer, surprisingly, is moral rather than epistemological.  Lewis was, for me, the indelible image of the Philosopher committed, as a moral imperative, to a search for clarity and understanding.  Although I think he would have been rather embarrassed to hear it said, Lew is radiated the conviction that in the study of Kant anything less than our complete commitment was a sin against truth.  In the Harvard Department in those days, or so I saw it, there were morally admirable professors, like John Wild, who however could not think their way out of a paper bag, and bright men for whom Philosophy was little more than a fascinating game.  Only Lewis combined rigor and clarity [and a grasp of Logic, which was essential in those days] with a moral commitment to the enterprise of Philosophy.

Seven years after taking Philosophy 130, I found myself teaching in the same room, from the same raised podium, behind the same desk where Lewis had sat so many times over the years.  I wrote to Lewis, who was then in retirement in California, to tell him that I was teaching his old course from the same podium, using his system of Kant summaries.  He wrote back to say that it was not his method but that of his professor.  Whom could that have been, all those years earlier?  Josiah Royce?  George Santayana?  I realize that I had somehow stumbled my way into a tradition of giants.  It was a daunting thought.

The first year that I taught the Kant course almost all of my students were undergraduates, but when I repeated the course the next year, twelve graduate students enrolled, some of them no younger than I was.  Among them were Margaret Dauler, later Margaret Wilson, and of course Thomas Nagel.  Saul Kripke, then an undergraduate, showed up for two or three weeks but apparently decided there was nothing there to interest him and stopped coming.

Well, ask me for a story and get a saga.  T. Gent, I hope this suffices for the moment.

Saturday, October 4, 2014

VIAGER


Yesterday evening, Susie and I went to see "My Old Lady," a new movie starring Maggie Smith, Kevin Kline, and Kristen Scott Thomas.  The movie is set in Paris in the Marais, the fourth arrondisement, and I recognized many of the street scenes because I pass that way on one of my morning walks.  [rue des Francs Bourgeois, etc.]  The plot revolves around a ninety-two year old woman, played by Maggie Smith [who is actually only seventy-nine], who lives in an enormous old run-down apartment with a huge magnificent garden.  She is living there en viager, which is the subject of this post.  [I shall not spoil the movie for anyone by revealing important elements of the plot.  Suffice it to say that it is a delight, with Kevin Kline in particular giving a wonderful performance.]

Throughout France, but especially in Paris, there are old folks who are what used to be called in the old days "land poor."  They own the apartments or houses in which they live, but they have very little in the way of ready cash for their final years.  Their homes have appreciated wildly over the years as a result of a continuing real estate boom, but if they were to cash out by selling, they would be faced with the painful necessity of moving, and then would be forced to spend all the money they had just realized buying a new home.

Enter the institution of the viager [which is French for "annuity."]  In France, you can sell your home and continue to live in it, the new owner being obliged by the contract to pay you a monthly stipend [called rente, although it is not rent in our sense since you are the one occupying the property, which you no longer own.]  When you die, the apartment or house becomes the property of the owner free and clear. 

The property is sold under these conditions for much, much less than it would be worth on the open market.  Indeed, the selling price is called a bouquet, which means just what it sounds like to an English speaker.  The suggestion is that the price is so low that it is just a bunch of flowers for the old lady, a bouquet.  The rente also is less than the property would bring in the rental market.

This sounds at first like what we call a reverse mortgage, but it is in fact quite different.  What we have here is a gamble, pure and simple.  The old lady or gentleman who sells en viager may drop dead five days after signing the contract, in which case the buyer has lucked into a very valuable property for a pittance.  The occupant may live for as number of years, during which the buyer is paying monthly rente and is, in effect, chipping away at the value of the purchase.  Or the occupant may live for a very long time, so long in fact that the original buyer dies and his or her heirs are stuck with the contract.  There is one story, apparently true, of a little old lady who lived en viager to become the oldest person in France!  The poor owner's heirs got stuck with her rente for decades.

When I went on-line to look up viager, I found a site offering properties all over France, on which the property is listed, along with the square meters [always, in France, the number one question], the normal market value, the bouquet, the monthly rente, and the sex and age of the occupant!  Two blocks from our apartment in Paris, on rue Lagrange, is a little real estate office that specializes in apartments en viager.  For a long time I was puzzled by their window each time I walked by until finally I looked it up.

All of this reminds me of the curious practice of the Tontine, which has figured in a number of movies and novels.  The institution of the viager seems to me to capture the quintessence of the French petit bourgeois mentality.  At all events, I recommend the movie.