Well, I have fussed as much as I can over my next lecture, in which I confront the very difficult first chapter of Capital. The high point of the lecture will be my imaginary field trips to a medieval Catholic Cathedral and a contemporary supermarket, the rationale for which I think I have already explained. I stayed up late last night watching Serena Williams play her last match, an emotionally rather wrenching experience. And of course, I have been keeping track of the steady march by the Justice Department toward indicting Donald Trump. But none of that is what has really been occupying my mind lately, and I thought I would take a few moments on this Saturday afternoon to write about what has been concerning me. This is quite personal and will be of almost no interest to all of you who comment on politics and such like things on this blog, but I would like to memorialize here what has been going on in my mind. It concerns my ongoing struggle to come to terms with my Parkinson’s disease – to come to terms with it both practically and also emotionally.
I have never been any sort of athlete, heaven knows,
although 75 years ago I was a member of a gymnastic team in my high school called
The Captain’s Corps. We worked out on
the parallel bars, walked around on our hands and such – not very impressive stuff –
but I gave all that up when I went to college and that was my last encounter
with organized athletics. Still and all, over the decades, I did the Canadian
Air Force exercises, swam each morning in the pool I had built in my
Massachusetts house with the proceeds from a successful textbook, and when I retired
and moved down to North Carolina, I began a regime of daily early morning walks
which I kept up for than 10 years. When Susie and I bought the apartment in Paris,
I began taking a one hour walk each morning around the fifth, sixth, and
seventh arrondissements, some of which I memorialized on this blog.
I continued the walks when we moved to Carolina Meadows five
years ago and it was a point of great, albeit rather sophomoric, pride that I
became known as an early morning walker. I got to know the other early morning
walkers and also their dogs and it helped me to deny that I was in fact growing
old. Then, a year and a half ago, I developed a tremor in my left hand and
after consulting three neurological specialists, looking for one who would give
me good rather than bad news, I was finally forced to accept the fact that I
had developed Parkinson’s disease.
I had seen several people here at Carolina Meadows in the
last stages of that terrible disease, bound to a wheelchair, virtually
immobile, looked after by their husbands or wives, and although my symptoms
were quite mild, I struggled terribly with the fact of my diagnosis. But I
continued to take my morning walks, pushing myself to get my heart rate up
because of literature I had been given to read by a physical therapist that
indicated that 30 minutes of aerobic exercise five days a week seemed to have the
effect of slowing down the progress of the disease.
Then, last October, disaster struck. At the end of one of my
walks I developed what is called “festination” which is an uncontrollable ever
more rapid walking in which, in effect, your feet run away with you until you
fall. I stumbled into the lobby of the building where I live, half fell against
the wall, lowered myself slowly to the floor, and could not get up until two
security guards saw me and helped me to my feet. My early morning walks were
over.
I bought a recumbent exercycle and began doing 30 minutes on
it five days a week, something that I have kept up faithfully ever since. But I
grew more and more unsteady and began to develop what the doctors describe as
freezing and stumbling as I walk, particularly when I am turning around or trying to make my way in the apartment from our bedroom to my bathroom or from
the kitchen to my study. I began to use
a three wheeled roller which I now take with me everywhere I go.
At first, I was embarrassed, ashamed, terribly
self-conscious about the fact that I was using the roller, even though in a retirement community like this one a great many other people use similar
devices.
Little by little, I have started to make accommodations and
adjustments in my life in response to the limitations imposed upon me by the
Parkinson’s. I have begun to take advantage of the transportation service
offered to residents here, both for myself and for Susie. Several weeks ago when I had some physical therapy sessions, the
transportation folks picked me up in front of our building and took me to the
health center so that I did not have to park and walk to the building.
I have already talked about the fact that the course I am
teaching meets not in the philosophy building, which at UNC Chapel Hill is
completely handicap inaccessible, but across campus in another building which
has a handicap accessible entrance in the rear. To help me with the frustrations
and complexities of navigating the UNC website and associated services and to
assist me in the classroom posting slides on the screen in front of the
blackboard, I hired a young man who has just completed his doctorate in
philosophy and who recorded and posted on YouTube my lectures on Marx, Freud,
and Kant.
All of this is of course relatively trivial and hardly
worthy of much comment, except that it has been extraordinarily difficult for
me to accept the fact that at the age of 88 with Parkinson’s disease, I can no
longer do what was easy for me to do even five years ago.
One of the lesser effects of Parkinson’s is a condition
called micrographia. My handwriting, which was never very good, has become so
crabbed and unsteady as to be unreadable.
Since I never did learn to touch type, I have spent my entire life
typing with my two forefingers but the Parkinson’s and the associated tremors
make that so random a process that I cannot rely on those fingers to write
anymore. Fortunately, there are dictation programs that are really quite good
and so as I sit here at my desk, I am speaking into a headphone and writing on
the computer much faster than I ever could have before.
Because of my condition, which is progressive and not
curable, and because I am also the principal caregiver to my wife, I decided to
sell our Paris apartment so that we would have the money we will need for ever
more extensive care as we grow older. My neurologist has been encouraging – she
says that the principal threat to my well-being at this point is my age, not my
disease. She expects that I will have 5 to 7 more years perhaps before I am
really constrained by the disease, and since at that point I would be perhaps
95 years old, if she is correct I cannot really complain. (Well, to be honest,
I can complain and I do so to myself a good deal, but that is neither here or
there.)
I appear to be cognitively undiminished, but everything is
harder for me now and takes me longer. I do not think I could teach two courses
or more at the same time as I did without the slightest difficulty during most
of my career.
But I do not think I shall go gentle into that good night,
and I shall most certainly rage against the dying of the light. Meanwhile, I
keep my spirits up by imagining Donald Trump indicted.
You I'd say qualify as a refugee from the old New York, as am I from a less old New York, as is the abominable Trump, though it would be okay for him to have a stay in Rikers on his way to confinement closer to Hell on earth
ReplyDeleteSorry about the process you're undergoing.
ReplyDeleteWhat you write above and previous posts are evidence that you are cognitively undiminished.
Youtube offered me a recent interview with Henry Kissinger who is 99. I listened to part of it: he doesn't look good (he never did look good), but his memory is excellent and he answered all the questions lucidly and intelligently.
I know he's not your favorite political figure, but if Kissinger made it to age 99 without
cognitive decline, maybe you can beat him.
RPW: My neurologist has been encouraging – she says that the principal threat to my well-being at this point is my age, not my disease. She expects that I will have 5 to 7 more years perhaps before I am really constrained by the disease
ReplyDeleteMy father was diagnosed with Parkinson's 15 or 20 years ago. He was only forced by the disease to give up driving about 3 years ago.
The plural of "anecdote" isn't "data." But there is certainly reason for optimism.
It is important for you to write about these medical matters and also for philosophers in general to listen more to the persons suffering from this long and disabling condition.
ReplyDeleteOne vocal human impacted by Parkinson's disease known also as Muhammad Ali wrote a beautiful memoir called The Soul of A Butterfly: Reflections on Life's Journey with his daughter Hana Ali's assistance in 2002, 14 years before his death at age 74 in 2016.
It explains his faith and philosophy from a more religious point of view than most would take today. Ali writes: "I think maybe my Parkinson's is God's way of reminding me of what is important: for example, how we treat each other. It slowed me down and caused me to listen rather than talk. Actually people pay more attention to me now because I don't talk so much" (page 147).
Ali never stops thinking like the butterfly: "I moved much quicker in my youth than I do these days, but for all that quickness, I missed a lot. Parkinson's has taught me to slow down and take smaller steps. I have learned to move at a different pace, and I have come to appreciate both quickness and stillness" (page 149).
Ali also appreciates the perspective of life of the ant: "My shaking and soft speech were harder for me to accept in the beginning. After a while, I began to realize that how I handled my illness had an effect on other people suffering from Parkinson's and other illnesses. Knowing that they counted one me gave me strength. And I realized again that I need people as much as they need me. I am as much at peace as I have ever been and I don't feel sorry for myself, so I don't want anyone else to feel sorry for me. What ever the future holds, I will come out on top. I am like that little ant in the front of the line; a lot of other ants depend on me, and they follow me" (page 153).
There is much more wisdom on living with Parkinson's in Ali's book, The Soul of A Butterfly and more philosophers should read it to appreciate Ali's unique resistance minded philosophy.
That was a wonderful quotation, and I agree 100% that such experiences as the Professor writes about here deserve far more attention by philosophers than they have typically received.
DeleteProfessor, you certainly have kept your erudite yet breezy prose style. Thank you for sharing these important life experiences with us.
Another well-regarded book dealing with declining health and the lessons of life is “Tuesdays With Morrie,” Mitch Albom’s memoir and tribute to his sociology professor at Brandeis, Morrie Schwartz, who was afflicted with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. One way or another, whether afflicted with a debilitating disease or illness, or not, this is a journey that we all must eventually traverse.
ReplyDeleteOne of my closest loved ones, my mom, was diagnosed with Parkinson's toward the end of last year, at the age of 69. She's still in an early stage (tremors are the main physical issue), and her neurologist has said that her brain is in comparatively quite good health, but nonetheless, as I heard my aunt say, "her world has been rocked." The anticipation of things to come is itself an ongoing battle.
ReplyDeleteIt just sucks. One feels that the best one can do is to be there, listen, and care.
Well, to be honest, I can complain and I do so to myself a good deal
ReplyDeleteI am glad of this. Whenever someone tells me that they can't complain, my standard retort is that they are not trying hard enough! You clearly are, and by keeping it to yourself, you are trying hard enough but are not trying (those around you).
The way you (are able to) write about this, so reflectively and objectively about your physical condition, but also so clearly about your feelings makes this especially moving.
ReplyDeleteMy wife's Parkinson's manifests itself primarily in balance problems. She also has had some (very understandable) depression, which is a frequently accompanies Parkinson's. It's important to be alert for that, and to seek treatment if it occurs.
I was well into my adulthood, probably late 40 or early 50s, before I even heard of Alzheimer's or Parkinson's. I once told my cardiologist that medicine's progress in treating heart disease and cancer has prolonged our lives enough for us to get neurological diseases. There have been times when I've wondered if it was worth it.
I offer, next to the wisdom of the great Muhammad Ali (whom I once saw fight Joe Frazier in their second of three fights), the beginning of the delightful essay by Marcus Tullius Cicero, statesman, philosopher, and sceptic, titled De Senectute (On Old Age), written in 45-43 BCE (?). The essay is written as a discourse by Cato the Elder then 84 years old, orator, scholar, conservative to the bone, opponent of Hellenism, known for ending all his speeches in the Senate with Carthago delenda est (Carthage must be destroyed). He was a bit of a bigot, but Cicero's work states at its beginning (translated by Lamberto Bozzi ):
ReplyDeleteOld age that is, which is already in sight,
And which makes us feel its unpleasant bite.
A bite and something else, I know for sure,
You can and will moderately endure.
But as soon as I was inclined
To write about senility
It was you who came to my mind
As worthy of a gratuity,
A gift we might well take as an excuse
To be converted to our mutual use.
Indeed the composition of this book
Was for me a pleasant task that took
Away not only age’s seamy side,
But helped me take senility in stride.
Philosophy can never get its due share
Of laudation since following its way
A man can go through life free from care.
When I was in Catholic high school many years ago, we were expected to translate passages like this from the Latin. Such, such were that days.
Be well and thrive Professor Wolff and take senility in stride and be free from care.